Our Menu

Mikey Likes It Ice Cream combines the best locally sourced ingredients in the New York area to create a product that is new, refreshing and unlike any other in today's food industry. Aside from our seasonal rotation of delectable flavors we offer customized flavors: you name it, we'll make it.

FLAVORS

ICE ICE BABY
Not just your traditional vanilla, this is triple vanilla. Enjoy a blend of three of the worlds most flavorful vanilla beans in every spoonful.
FOXY BROWN
If you love mocha now add crushed chocolate wafer cookies and a sea salt caramel swirl. Don't mess around we're just talking about Foxy Brown!
TRUFFLE SHUFFLE
What happens when you mix milk chocolate ice cream with your favorite mini semi-sweet chocolate chips and mini chocolate covered marshmallows? A chocolate explosion that will have you craving more.
MINT CONDITION
Wouldn't you fall in love with the coolness of natural mint and triple fudge chocolate brownie pieces? If not, you're breaking my heart.
PINK FLOYD
Take a walk on the dark side of the moon with this double strawberry and cheesecake treat.
DOUGH BOY
Chocolate brownie dough pieces are combined with chocolate chip cookie dough pieces to make Mikey's version this classic flavor.

SOUTHERN HOSPITALITY
If you love butter pecan, this is for you! Enjoy this pecan ice cream with praline pecans and chunks of pecan pie.

THE COOKIE JAR
We stole the cookie from the cookie jar and made you a dairy free cookies 'n creme ice cream.

BRADY BUNCH
Banana pudding, Vienna Fingers, and crushed vanilla wafers met ice cream. That's the way they all became the Brady Bunch.

 

EXTRAS

MAC DADDY
Half waffle ice cream sandwich with your choice of ice cream and flavored waffle
MILLI VANILLI
Coke or root beer float served with two scoops of your choice of ice cream
DADDY MAC
Whole waffle ice cream sandwich with your choice of ice cream and flavored waffle
NICE & SMOOTH
Mikey Likes It signature milkshake w/ your choice of healthy ice cream made with coconut water, soy milk, or almond milk
2 LIVE CREW
Mikey Likes It signature milkshake with your choice of ice cream
THE HUMPTY DANCE
Mikey Likes It signature egg cream with your choice of ice cream